Advertisement
278 Lt Lonsdale Street Melbourne. © Peddle Thorp

Planning Application: 278 Little Lonsdale Street, Melbourne

Today we look at a planning application for a 59-storey residential tower on the site of Phillip Shirts at 274-276 Little Lonsdale Street. The Peddle Thorp-designed tower would join two other recent projects for Brady Corp in Melbourne Sky and Melbourne Star as it shares a boundary and obscures the latter's eastern wall.

Current Phillips Shirts building on site. © Peddle Thorp

Approval is sought to demolish the majority of an existing three storey brick building to accommodate the apartment tower. The existing façade will be retained along the Little Lonsdale Street frontage and will continue along Zevenboom Lane for approximately 17.4 metres. A good outcome considering it has been identified as having little heritage significance.

Whilst it is noted this façade has not been heritage listed, it is considered that this existing façade contributes positively to the streetscape (including in terms of scale and rhythm of window openings) and is worthy of retention to enhance the streetscape address of the site. Furthermore, its adaption will form an appealing feature of the proposed development scheme at the site.

Urbis Planning Report

A wrap of two ground level retail tenancies addresses the Little Lonsdale Street and Zevenboom Lane corner. The main entry lobby, loading facilities and other ancillary services complete the ground floor with bicycle parking and car parking reserved for the four basement levels.

Retained facade to Little Lonsdale Street and Zevenboom Lane © Peddle Thorp

Urban Context

The proposal lies in a quarter of the city currently undergoing a significant transformation with projects such as Eporo Tower, Carlson Tower and Latrobe Tower to the immediate north and 380 Lonsdale Street to the south. 278 Little Lonsdale would be one of the taller buildings in the area as illustrated by the diagram below:

Existing building heights diagram. © Peddle Thorp

This wouldn't be of concern unless you factor in the site footprint relative to some of the other towers of similar height. At 735sqm the site is significantly smaller than the foortprints of Melbourne Central and the future development at 380 Lonsdale Street. These towers also have frontages along major CBD streets whereas the development is within a largely small scale 'neighbourhood' defined by red brick low-rise buildings bisected by a network of laneways.

The Tower

The main tower element rising behind the retained facade shares an aesthetic quality with its older yet shorter siblings to the west. Sheer glazed curtain walls are interrupted by the revealing of balconies behind.

Similarly to Australia 108 the facade features a stripped gradation from top to bottom with the stripes becoming incrementally more contracted towards the tower's pinnicale. This volume above a 'podium' with a furrier treatment involves a bronze coloured veil similar to original designs for another Peddle Thorp design, Vision tower at 500 Elizabeth Street. This splash of colour continues to the western boundary of the tower in the form of solid spandrels which rise up the remainder of the tower.

278 Lt Lonsdale Street in situ. © Peddle Thorp

Project Summary

  • Building height: 59-storeys, 186m to top of plant
  • Retention of Phillips Shirts' facade
  • 314 apartments in total
  • 127 x 1 Bed, 144 x 2 Bed, 43 x 3 Bed
  • 42 car spaces serviced via car stacker system to basement levels 2-4
  • 94 Bicycle spaces to basement level 1
  • 158sqm of ground floor retail

Comment

The proposed development continues the recent trend of large scale high-rises encroaching on the relatively low scale streetscapes which define Melbourne's 'Little' streets and laneways. I've always been a proponent for skyscrapers in the CBD, I won't shy away from that fact, however I don't consider developments of this scale to be appropriate responses to the character and grain of these areas.

The footprints of these sites is generally much smaller than the larger sites on the primary CBD streets. This results in narrow skyscrapers with two shared boundaries that if built to the extremity as usually tends to occur, creates a 'wall' effect that is amplified on much smaller streets from a pedestrian perspective.

I don't consider this to be a desirable outcome and would invite anyone to tell me otherwise or convince me that these are the type of streets we wish to create moving forward. The benchmark for development in these smaller scale streets should be the more modest additions found on McKillop Street or Hardware Lane - unobtrusive yet worth tilting your head up to appreciate. Leave the big towers to the major streets and their intersections.

Project Team

  • Developer: 278 Little Lonsdale Pty Ltd
  • Architecture: Peddle Thorp
  • Planning: Urbis
  • ESD: SBE
  • Traffic: Cardno
  • Waste: Wastech

5 comments

Bilby's picture

Your analysis is spot on, Laurence. The only thing I would add is that the retention of the heritage street façade, while worthy in itself, doesn't address the major heritage values of the site - i.e. the existing low-scale historic frontage to Zevenboom lane. This could have been another perfect red-brick laneway frontage to activate with small scale lane-front shops and tenancies of various kinds. If this tower goes ahead, it will be a dark, characterless, forbidding space in the central city - and one of a growing list of once-on-a-lifetime lost opportunites in Melbourne planning.

Back to top
Paul Anderson's picture

I agree that it's too imposing for a "little" street however am pleased they are maintaining the frontage .. that's one trend I wish would take off in our city.

Back to top
Bilby's picture

Yes, but are they maintaining the character of the frontage? And are they maintaining enough of the red brick lane way frontage (lane ways are equally important as main "streets" in Melbourne these days). The answer is no. The plan appears to be to render and paint the red brick facade and demolish most of the historic lane scape.

Back to top
Riccardo's picture

Honestly, with the grief, the accumulated grief and grinding of teeth that this has caused over decades and over thousands of people, maybe we should have gone 'La Defense' many decades ago. Left the Pre-war or rather pre-depression Melbourne 'as is' inside its Hoddle Grid and Hoddle Plan suburbs.

And then expelled the railways and freight forwarders from Docklands and West Melbourne a long time ago, and built a New Melbourne all shiny and tall. Indulged the NIMBYs and the establishment with their fetish for old buildings, but equally allowed Melbourne to grow and prosper with new development and new designs that suited the modern age. And put in place that none of that would ever be heritage listed - made it explicit that the buildings in New Melbourne would be time limited by market conditions.

Back to top
Bilby's picture

Yes, that would have been a reasonable idea. I'm not sure that heritage advocates would have such a problem with demolishing certain historic buildings if we were seeing quality contemporary design replacing them, however. Unfortunately in the main, in terms of their design and liveability characteristics, the historic offers much more to our contemporary cities than the new.

Back to top

Development & Planning

Friday, March 24, 2017 - 06:00
Planning Minister Richard Wynne has approved another commercial tower at Lendlease's Melbourne Quarter development in the Docklands. The building known as Melbourne Quarter Tower will be located at 693 Collins Street, injecting almost 55,000sqm of office space into the precinct across its 28 floors, in addition to approximately 2,500sqm of retail space.

Policy, Culture & Opinion

Thursday, March 9, 2017 - 12:00
As part of the enabling stage of the Queen Victoria Market Renewal Project, the City of Melbourne has finally revealed their plans for the former Munro site, to be developed by PDG Corporation into a mixed-use development comprising a 58-storey Bates Smart designed-tower of 308 dwellings and a 300-room hotel, after the developer was awarded the rights to develop the site on CoM's behalf.

Visual Melbourne

Wednesday, February 22, 2017 - 07:00
Once again Melbourne has turned it on for the spectacular cultural juggernaut that is White Night. A crowd of around 600,000 took part in the all night festival of projections, performances, artworks and installations. Stealing the show again this year was the extraordinary projections upon the Royal Exhibition Building.

Advertisement

Transport & Design

Thursday, March 23, 2017 - 12:00
The large-scale redevelopment of Richmond's former Jaques engineering complex has been marked by an number of onsite dedications. Dating back to 1885 and with frontages to Palmer, Coppin, Dyer and Griffiths Streets, the 9,945sqm site's engineering heritage has been permanently embossed across the site.

Sustainability & Environment

Tuesday, March 14, 2017 - 13:00
Victoria Walks, a walking promotion charity supported by VicHeath, is leading a crowdsourcing initiative that is supported by the State Government and 14 councils. The campaign aims to collect and analyse opinions on walking right across the Melbourne metropolitan area. The authorities are asking people to indicate their walking safety concerns through an interactive online map on CrowdSpot's platform.